Scale & fate of the universe

Heat death of the universe

The last stars go out, black holes evaporate, and nothing is left that can change

Theoretical Artist's impression · drag to rotate
Also called the Big Freeze or Big Chill [1]
Idea from the 1850s Rudolf Clausius and William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) [1]
Last stars form by about 10¹⁴ years a hundred trillion years from the start [2]
Degenerate era about 10¹⁵ to 10³⁷ years only dead stars remain [3]
Black hole era about 10³⁸ to 10¹⁰⁰ years until the last ones evaporate [3]
Supported by accelerating expansion discovered 1998 [5]
Certain? no [1]

About the image. Drawn as an almost empty darkness with a few cold, dead stars and one black hole giving off its last faint glow. The scene is imagined: it shows a time so far in the future that it cannot be observed, only calculated.

A hot cup of coffee cools until it matches the room. A ball rolls downhill and stops. Left alone, energy always spreads out, and the measure of that spreading, entropy, only grows. Applied to the whole universe, the same rule suggests an ending: a far future in which energy is spread so evenly that nothing can happen any more. That end is called the heat death of the universe.

A 19th-century idea

The idea comes from the founders of thermodynamics. In the early 1850s Rudolf Clausius in Germany and William Thomson, later Lord Kelvin, in Britain set out the second law of thermodynamics. Thomson wrote of a “universal tendency in nature to the dissipation of mechanical energy” and drew the conclusion that the Earth, and eventually the universe, would run down.

Heat death does not mean the universe becomes hot. It means it reaches the same temperature everywhere. With no temperature differences left, no engine, no star and no living thing can extract useful energy. The more common modern name is the Big Freeze, because in an expanding universe that uniform temperature is close to absolute zero.

The long goodbye

In 1997 Fred Adams and Gregory Laughlin worked out what would happen to the universe over unimaginable spans of time. Their timeline, measured in powers of ten, runs roughly like this:

  • By about 10¹⁴ years, a hundred trillion years from the start, the gas for new stars runs out and the last small red dwarfs fade.
  • From about 10¹⁵ to 10³⁷ years, the universe holds only the remains of stars: white dwarfs cooling to black dwarfs, neutron stars and black holes. If protons decay, which has never been observed, these remains slowly dissolve.
  • From about 10³⁸ to 10¹⁰⁰ years, black holes are the last large objects. Each one slowly loses mass as Hawking radiation and finally evaporates. The largest take longest.
  • After that comes a dark era of scattered particles and faint radiation, ever more thinly spread, with nothing left to change.

Why it is the likeliest end

In 1998 two teams studying distant supernovae found that the expansion of the universe is speeding up, a discovery that earned the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics. If the expansion continues as it is now, galaxies will drift ever further apart, and the universe will cool towards heat death.

That conclusion is not certain. It depends on the nature of dark energy, which is still unknown. If dark energy grows stronger, the universe might end in a Big Rip instead; if our vacuum is unstable, it could end suddenly in vacuum decay. Some physicists also question whether the entropy of an entire universe can be defined at all.

Gallery

A dark sphere wrapped in a faint, warped orange ring of light in an otherwise dim brown sky, an impression of a black hole in the far future of the universe. AI-generated painting.
A dim red star glowing on the left and a cold, dark planet lit faintly from its side, an impression of the heat death of the universe. AI-generated painting.
Heat death of the universe, 3D artist's impression, rendered from the interactive model.
Heat death of the universe, 3D artist's impression, from another angle, rendered from the interactive model.
Heat death of the universe, 3D artist's impression, close-up, rendered from the interactive model.

Timeline

  1. 1850s Clausius and Thomson set out the second law of thermodynamics and the dissipation of energy.
  2. 1997 Adams and Laughlin publish their timeline of the far future.
  3. 1998 The expansion of the universe is found to be accelerating.
  4. 2011 The discovery wins the Nobel Prize in Physics.

Questions people ask

What is the heat death of the universe?

A possible end in which energy is spread so evenly that no temperature differences remain, so nothing can do work and nothing changes.

When will the heat death of the universe happen?

There is no single date. The last stars fade by about 10¹⁴ years, and the last black holes evaporate around 10¹⁰⁰ years.

Is heat death certain?

No. It depends on dark energy, which is not understood. A Big Rip or vacuum decay are other possibilities.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Heat death of the universe
  2. Wikipedia: Future of an expanding universe
  3. Adams & Laughlin 1997: A dying universe (Reviews of Modern Physics 69, 337)
  4. Adams & Laughlin (1997), A dying universe, Reviews of Modern Physics 69: 337
  5. Wikipedia: Accelerating expansion of the universe