Black holes & exotica

White hole

A region of space that nothing can enter and everything must leave. The mathematics allows it; nature may not

Hypothetical Artist's impression · drag to rotate
What it is a black hole reversed in time [1]
Can be entered? no matter and light can only leave [2]
Proposed 1964 Igor Novikov [1]
Evidence none [1]
Stability unstable Douglas Eardley, 1974 [3]
Known way to form one none [1]

About the image. Drawn as a brilliant sphere pouring out light and matter in every direction, the reverse of a black hole. No white hole has ever been observed, and nobody knows what one would look like.

The equations of general relativity work just as well run backwards in time. A black hole is a region that anything can fall into and nothing can leave. Run the film in reverse, and you get its opposite: a region that nothing can fall into and that everything must leave. That is a white hole.

In the mathematics

The idea comes from the complete mathematical description of a simple, non-rotating black hole. Written out in full, in the coordinates found by Martin Kruskal and George Szekeres, the solution has four regions: our universe outside, the black hole, a second, parallel universe outside, and a white hole. Matter and light can escape from the white hole region, but can never return to it. The Soviet physicist Igor Novikov discussed such objects in 1964.

Stephen Hawking argued that in a sense black and white holes may be two faces of the same thing: the time reversal of a black hole in thermal equilibrium is a white hole in thermal equilibrium.

Why physicists doubt them

There is no evidence that white holes exist, and very few scientists expect them to. The white hole region in the mathematics exists only for an eternal black hole. Black holes that form from collapsing stars, the only kind we know, do not have one.

They would also be fragile. In 1974 Douglas Eardley showed that a white hole would be unstable: matter falling towards it from outside would pile up and quickly turn it into a black hole. And there is no known way for one to form in the first place.

Bold ideas

Some physicists have explored the idea anyway. In 2011 Alon Retter and Shlomo Heller suggested that a white hole would release all its matter in a single burst, a “Small Bang”, and proposed that some unusual gamma-ray bursts might be white holes. They also noted that the Big Bang itself has been described as a kind of white hole. In 2014 Hal Haggard and Carlo Rovelli proposed that quantum effects might eventually turn a black hole into a white hole, releasing what fell in long ago.

Quasars were once considered as possible white holes. That idea has long been abandoned: they are powered by supermassive black holes. White holes remain a possibility of the mathematics with no known place in nature.

Gallery

A blazing white ring with streams of light pouring outwards from it in every direction, an impression of a white hole. AI-generated painting.
A violent burst of golden light and matter exploding outwards from a single point against a starfield, an impression of a white hole erupting. AI-generated painting.
White hole, 3D artist's impression, rendered from the interactive model.
White hole, 3D artist's impression, from another angle, rendered from the interactive model.
White hole, 3D artist's impression, close-up, rendered from the interactive model.

Timeline

  1. 1964 Igor Novikov discusses white holes.
  2. 1974 Douglas Eardley shows white holes would be unstable.
  3. 2011 Retter and Heller propose white holes as 'Small Bangs'.
  4. 2014 Haggard and Rovelli propose black holes may turn into white holes.

Questions people ask

Do white holes exist?

Probably not. There is no evidence for them, and most physicists think they do not exist in nature.

What is the difference between a black hole and a white hole?

Nothing can escape a black hole; nothing can enter a white hole. Mathematically, one is the other run backwards in time.

Is the Big Bang a white hole?

Probably not. That has been proposed as a speculative idea, but it is not the standard view.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: White hole
  2. Wikipedia: Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates
  3. Eardley (1974), Death of white holes in the early universe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 33: 442
  4. Retter & Heller (2012), The revival of white holes as Small Bangs, New Astronomy
  5. Haggard & Rovelli (2015), Black hole fireworks: quantum-gravity effects outside the horizon spark black to white hole tunneling, Phys. Rev. D 92